Creative AI meetup #15: Existential Risk and Computational Creativity – 11th January 2018

The Creative AI meetup is designed to bring together artists, developers, designers, technologists and industry professionals to discuss applications of artificial intelligence in the creative industries.

January’s talk discussed  existential risk and computational creativity.

Shahar Avin of Centre for the Study of Existential Risk presented his work on a superintelligence modification (mod) for Sid Meier’s Civilization® V, a popular turn-based strategy game. The aim of the mod is to concretise some of the issues surrounding catastrophic AI risks, and to put individuals in a situation that makes both the risks and possible solutions accessible.

The mod allows the player to pursue victory through technological superiority, via developing a safe superintelligence, while introducing associated risks from rogue superintelligence, which could lead to human extinction (and game loss). Players can allocate resources to AI research and to AI safety research, negotiate AI treaties with other civilisations, all while balancing the demands of all the other interlocking systems of the game, including trade, diplomacy and warfare. The mod was made available to a closed group of testers and the responses were mixed, highlighting some of the difficulties of concretising abstract concepts in this area, while also suggesting certain key characteristics of the domain are amenable to treatment through the medium of a video game.

An interesting discussion at the end included one audience member mentioning versions of Civilization® that have been played solely by AI, all of which have ended in destruction and the end of the game. The lesson seemingly being that the modelling suggests that time spent on developing safe superintelligences could avert catastrophic risks and ultimately human extinction.

Simon Colton explored ways in which generative systems can evolve into genuinely creative, autonomous systems, drawing on 20 years of Computational Creativity research.

Simon’s talk was entitled “From Creative AI to Computational Creativity and Back Again”.

One of the maxims emerging from the Creative AI movement, fuelled by developments in generative deep learning models, is the notion of producing the highest quality output possible from creative systems. If we accept that how and why an artwork was produced is often taken into consideration when value judgements are made, then the academic field of Computational Creativity has much to offer to help Creative AI practitioners. Simon explored ways in which generative systems can evolve into genuinely creative, autonomous systems, drawing on 20 years of Computational Creativity research. Conversely, the remarkable power of generative networks to hallucinate images, music and text represents a real boon for Computational Creativity researchers interested in the simulation of imaginative behaviour, and also upon the ways in which we are currently (and could in future) harness this power to explore practical and philosophical aspects surrounding the idea that software can be creative.

The most interesting aspects of the talk were his assertion that there is no agreed definition of creativity, and the idea that the context of a piece of creative work counts for much. If we know an artwork is made solely by AI, we judge it very differently, and usually negatively.

Simon Colton is a Professor of Digital Games Technologies at Falmouth University and a part-time Professor of Computational Creativity at Goldsmiths College. He is an AI researcher specialising in questions of Computational Creativity — getting software to autonomously create artefacts of real value in interesting ways. He has published nearly 200 papers and his research has won national and international prizes. He is most well known for the software he has written and co-written to make mathematical discoveries; paint pictures; make games and generate fictional ideas, including The Painting Fool. He’s also known for his philosophical and theoretical contributions to Computational Creativity, in particular driving forward the assessment of creative software via what it does, rather than what it produces.

Kiri – ‘out-takes’

During the process of developing the Kiri game for the PG02 Cycle 1 ‘Accomplices’ brief, there were some variations that weren’t incorporated in the final game, but I thought might be interesting to note for future development.

One previous idea for the game was as follows:

The aim of the game is to encourage people to plant new trees / seeds / plants in ‘restricted’ areas (based on a near-future where all land is privately owned). So private citizens planting seeds anywhere is now a crime.

By growing trees / seeds, the plants and planters can connect with each other and begin to reclaim the land where not enough plant life is growing to sustain the planet.

The Accomplice brings back seeds from Mars / Future Planet which grow more quickly and larger than Earth plants. Would be interesting to design and 3D print these ‘Future Planet’ flowers.

As the networks connect, each team / player has access to more seeds and can cross-pollinate newer, better seeds and plants. These networks may connect only via the augmented reality part of the game, invisible to the players until they discover it (the markers might be the only clue to its existence).

The aim of this game is to breed new plant varieties by working with other teams, thus replanting the Earth and encouraging diversity.

Locations – set locations on Google Maps, eg. parks, specific trees, private spaces. The game could be played outside, on large boards or street markings.

The game players plant actual (or genetically modified / ‘biohacked’) seeds and sign-in at the various locations with hand gestures to their camera phones. Air or light paintings.

Suggested hand gestures for checking in
Suggested hand gestures for checking in

Packaging ideas:

Kiri game packaging concept
Kiri game packaging concept
Kiri game packaging concept
Kiri game packaging concept

Save

Kiri – The Conservation game

Today was the final presentation for the PG02 Cycle 1 project. Lots of great feedback and questions during the presentation as to how this game could be developed and researched further. Starting with how games are marketed and developed. Also lots to think about in terms of taking this away from the physical analogue game & board and into developing the augmented reality part much further.

Lots of fun to work on, but also looking forward now to the next brief.

Here are some photos from the final game.

Kiri - game board & pieces
Kiri – game board & pieces
Kiri - game board & pieces
Kiri – game board & pieces
Kiri - game board & pieces
Kiri – game board & pieces
Kiri - game board & pieces
Kiri – game board & pieces